• Florida Championship Wrestling
  • FCW Florida Tag Team Championship (2 lần) – với Brad Allen (1) Gavin Spears (1)
• Pro Wrestling Illustrated
  • PWI ranked him 9 of the top 500 singles wrestlers in the PWI 500 in 2013
• Rolling Stone
  • Worst Storyline (2015)[309] with Lana vs. Rusev/Summer Rae
  • WWE Wrestler of the Year (2014)[184]
• World Wrestling Entertainment/WWE
  • World Heavyweight Championship (2 lần)[310][311]
  • World Tag Team Championship (1 lần)1 – với The Spirit Squad[19]
  • WWE Intercontinental Championship (6 lần, hiện tại)70[312][313][314]]]
  • WWE United States Championship (2 lần)[91]
  • Money in the Bank (2012 – World Heavyweight Championship contract)[123]
  • Slammy Awards (2 lâ)n
    • Best Twitter Handle or Social Champion (2014) – @HEELZiggler[315]
    • Match of the Year (2014) – Team Cena vs. Team Authority at Survivor Series[315]
  • 22nd Triple Crown Champion
• Wrestling Observer Newsletter
  • Most Improved (2011)[316]
  • Most Underrated (2011)[316]

1 Ziggler, as Nicky, defended the championship with either Kenny, Johnny, Mitch or Mikey under the Freebird Rule.